20 Jun 2007

Mechanical Ventilation with Heat Recovery

One of the little discussed details surrounding the Passive House debate is the use and abuse of mechanical ventilation. The Passivhaus standard insists on it: other low energy standards are not so prescriptive. I believe that the way the new Code for Sustainable Homes standards have been drafted, the top levels more or less ape the Passivhaus standard and therefore mechanical ventilation with heat recovery will become de rigeur.

The issue underlying all this is the ever-present contradiction between saving energy and maintaining good indoor air quality. You have to have fresh air inside a home and this fresh air has to be heated (or sometimes cooled) in order for it to remain comfortable indoors. However well you insulate the fabric of the structure, you still have this energy demand to deal with. The energy load naturally varies according to the outside conditions, but it can often be more than 1kW, sometimes even 2kW. That represents around half the overall heat load for the house.

Now the Passive House approach is to first reduce the air leakage of the structure to an absolute minimum. This ensures that you don’t have to heat more air than you actually require. Then you run inlet and outlet ducts around the house and you draw in the fresh air via a heat exchanger, which pulls as much heat as possible out of the exhaust air. This is what is known as a Mechanical Ventilation System with Heat Recovery. The acronym we use in the UK is MVHR.

These air-to-air heat exchangers have been getting more and more efficient over the years and some claim to recapture as much as 90% of the heat from the exhaust air. Also the electric fans that drive them have also been getting more efficient, thus further increasing the CoP (Coefficient of Performance).

Even with a 90% recovery rate, you still need an additional heat source to keep the house warm, but not much. You have reduced the overall heat loss to a minimum. The structure doesn’t transmit much heat, the air leakage is all but eliminated and the supply air is pre-heated by the exhaust air. It’s technically very difficult to do much more than this and this is essentially why the Passivhaus standard is regarded so highly by our energy wonks.

But there are health concerns that have yet to be fully addressed here. Whilst much of the world lives fairly happily with ducted air heating systems, they are not without their problems and issues. And the typical North American home, where this form of heating and air conditioning is the norm, is not built to anything like the airtightness specifications demanded by the Passivhaus standard. What will happen if you a) force people to build to really demanding air tightness levels and then b) force them to use mechanical systems to manage their air supply? We’ve seen a few thousand homes built to these exacting standards in Europe and as yet no one has reported any major problems with air quality. But the UK is proposing to roll out such standards on an unprecedented scale, albeit after 2016. Is this really practicable? Or even sensible?

Take a look at this guidance, emanating from the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation recently, on what you need to do to keep your MVHR (which they refer to as HRV) systems tickety-boo. There is a surprisingly long list of maintenance issues to be attended to. Do you really think all UK homeowners will do this? And what will happen if (and when) they don’t?


Your heat recovery ventilator (HRV) can help make your house a clean, healthy living environment, while keeping fuel bills down. But your HRV can't do all this without your help.
It only takes seven simple steps to keep your HRV happy…

The Seven Steps to a Happy HRV

First turn off the HRV and unplug it.

• Step 1: Clean or Replace Air Filters
Dirty or clogged filters can lower ventilation efficiency. Try to clean your filters at least every two months. Filters in most new HRVs can be easily removed, cleaned with a vacuum cleaner, then washed with mild soap and water before being replaced. Older units have replaceable filters. If your HRV is easily accessible, this is a 5 minute job.

• Step 2: Check Outdoor Intake and Exhaust Hoods
Remove leaves, waste paper or other obstructions that may be blocking the outside vents of your HRV. Without this vital airflow, your HRV won't function properly. During winter, clear any snow or frost buildup blocking outside vents.

• Step 3: Inspect the Condensate Drain
Check to see if your HRV has a condensate drain, a pipe or plastic tube coming out of the bottom. If it does, slowly pour about two litres of warm, clean water in the drain inside the HRV to make sure it's flowing freely. If there's a backup, clean the drain.

• Step 4: Clean the Heat Exchange Core
Check your HRV owner's manual for instructions on cleaning the heat exchange core. Vacuuming the core and washing it with soap and water will reduce dust which can build up inside the core.

• Step 5: Clean Grilles and Inspect the Ductwork
Once a year, check the ductwork leading to and from your HRV. Remove and inspect the grilles covering the duct ends, then vacuum inside the ducts. If a more thorough cleaning is required, call your service technician.

• Step 6: Service the Fans
Remove the dirt that has accumulated on the blades by gently brushing them. Most new HRVs are designed to run continuously without lubrication, but older models require a few drops of proper motor lubricating oil in a designated oil intake. Check your manual for complete instructions.

• Step 7: Arrange for Annual Servicing
Your HRV should be serviced annually. If you are not comfortable doing it yourself, contact a technician accredited by the Heating, Refrigerating and Air Conditioning Institute of Canada. Make sure the technician you call has been trained by the manufacturer of your HRV.

Check Your HRV Balance: the Garbage Bag Test
HRVs need to be balanced, with the fresh air flow matching the exhaust flow. If you do not know if the HRV was balanced when installed or if you have changed or added HRV ducts, you may want to check the balance with the following simple procedure. This rough test will take about 10 minutes.

Use a large plastic leaf collection bag, typically 1.2m (48 in.) long. Untwist a wire coat hanger. Tape the wire to the mouth of the bag to keep it open. You now have a garbage bag flow tester. Go outside to where your HRV ducts exit the foundation.

• Step 1:
Crush the bag flat and hold the opening tightly over the exhaust hood. The air flowing out of the hood will inflate the bag. Time the inflation. If the bag inflates in eight seconds or more, go to Step 2. If the bag inflates in less than eight seconds, turn the HRV to a lower speed, and repeat the test. Then go to Step 2.

• Step 2:
Swing the bag to inflate it and hold the opening against the wall around the HRV supply hood. The air going into the HRV will now deflate the bag. Time the deflation. If your HRV is balanced, air going into the HRV will balance the air coming out of the HRV. The inflation and deflation times should be roughly equal. If you find that the bag inflates twice as fast as it deflates, for instance, your HRV is unbalanced. If you can see no problem with the filters that would cause such an imbalance, you should call a service person to test and adjust your HRV.

Please don't ignore your HRV. Just a little bit of your time is all it takes to keep it running smoothly.

• April or May
— Turn dehumidistat (the adjustable control on many HRVs which activates the HRV according to relative humidity) to HIGH setting or to OFF.

• September or October
— Clean core
— Check fans
— Check condensate drain
— Check grilles and ducts in house
— Reset humidistat (40%–80%)


  1. Hi,
    Excellent knowledge provided. Mechanical ventilation will probably be needed in winter; a heat recovery ventilator, which preheats incoming air, is a good option.Indoor air quality is best controlled with mechanical ventilation and may involve the use of ceiling fans or exhaust vents. Natural ventilation uses much less energy than mechanical, but is also less efficient at maintaining air quality or replacing room air in a timely manner. Windows that open and trickle vents are types of natural ventilation.


  2. Mechanical Ventilation is for cold or winter, this is good job for home care. Our organization have the services of Heat Recovery Ventilation.